Attendoformerly Petpooja Payroll
Workforce & HR Management

70 Performance Appraisal Comments With Real Examples

Ready comments for every appraisal rating and skill, overall remarks, and self appraisal lines for employees, with what to avoid.

By Ashwiniba Vaghela

· 19 min read

Listen to this article

0:000:00
Performance appraisal meeting showing an HR manager discussing employee feedback, goal achievement and performance evaluation with a colleague.

Performance appraisal comments are the short notes a manager writes beside each rating, saying what the employee did well and what to improve. Good ones quote real work, not adjectives.

Many owners, managers and human resources (HR) teams write them once a year, with a pile of forms and the same three phrases for everyone.

Below are 70 performance appraisal comments: by rating, by skill, overall comments, and self appraisal comments for employees. In my view, a comment without a dated example is only an opinion.

Key Takeaways

  • A good comment pairs a real example with a next step, so the employee knows what to repeat or change.
  • Match the comment to the rating. A “meets expectations” note should not read like an outstanding one.
  • Write about the work only, never about age, gender, health or leave the employee was entitled to.
  • Employees can comment too, in a self appraisal and in the box after the manager’s review.

Latest Update on Appraisal-Linked Pay
The Labour Ministry’s FAQs of 16 March 2026 say annual performance-based incentives are not “wages” under the labour codes. A yearly incentive tied to an appraisal rating does not change the wage figure the codes use.

What Good Appraisal Comments Contain

A useful comment has four parts: what you saw, a dated example with a month or a number, the effect on customers, the team or the business, and what next. The examples below keep the parts short, so replace each detail with the real one.

For example, a comment for a customer support executive could read: “Solves billing queries on the first call, and closed 46 of 50 queries this way in March. Customers waited less for an answer. Next quarter: train two new joiners on it.”

1 WHAT YOU SAW Solves billing queries on the first call. 2 A DATED EXAMPLE Closed 46 of 50 queries this way in March. 3 THE EFFECT Customers waited less for an answer. 4 WHAT NEXT Next quarter: train two new joiners on it. Four parts make one comment an employee can act on. An example comment for a customer support executive.
One appraisal comment split into its four parts: what you saw, a dated example, the effect and what next.

Leave out a part and the comment gets weaker. Without the example it is an opinion, and without the next step the employee has nothing to work on.

Use the same appraisal form for every employee, so the comments can be compared.

In Simple Words
An appraisal comment is a short note about your work. It says what you did well. It says what to do better. A good note uses a real example.

Performance Appraisal Comments by Rating

Many forms rate employees on a five-point scale. These examples of performance appraisal comments are grouped by that rating, from 5 down to 1, so the words match the score.

5 4 3 2 1 Rating 5: Outstanding Well beyond target, all year. Rating 4: Exceeds expectations Above target in most areas. Rating 3: Meets expectations On target: the job done well. Rating 2: Needs improvement Below target in key areas. Rating 1: Unsatisfactory Well below target, even with support. Match each comment to the rating it sits beside. Your own form may use other names or a different scale.
A five-point appraisal scale, from 5 for outstanding down to 1 for unsatisfactory, with what each rating usually means.

Use the comments as a starting point, then change the details so each one describes the person in front of you.

Rating 5: Comments for Outstanding Work

Use these for an employee who went well beyond the target for the whole review period, not for one strong month. The comment should say what made the year stand out, so the rating and any raise that follows are easy to explain.

Name the result and its effect on the business, such as new customers won or less rework on the line, and add what a top performer could take on in the coming year. An appreciation letter can say the same thanks in writing.

  1. Beat every monthly sales target this year and opened 14 new outlets, the most in the team.
  2. Solved problems before they reached the manager, such as fixing the delayed stock order in June.
  3. Trained three new joiners who now work on their own; mentoring the next batch is a good next step.
  4. Set the quality standard on the line, with only two reworked batches in twelve months.

Rating 4: Comments for Exceeding Targets

These suit an employee who went beyond the target in most areas and most months, but not all of them. The comment should credit the extra effort clearly and say what would lift the next rating to outstanding in the coming year.

Keep the praise specific, because vague praise sounds the same for everyone. A line about covering the festival rush or customers asking for the employee by name tells the person exactly what the manager noticed and valued.

  1. Beat the target in nine of twelve months and kept quality high while doing it.
  2. Takes on extra work without being asked, such as covering eight evening shifts during the Diwali rush.
  3. Customers asked for this employee by name in 12 feedback forms this year.
  4. Ready for more responsibility; leading a small team could be the next step when a role opens.

Rating 3: Comments for Meeting Targets

Meets expectations is a good rating, not a weak one: the job was done to the standard agreed. Many steady, reliable employees land here, so the comment should thank them and name one way to grow, without sounding like a warning.

Avoid comments that hint at a problem when there is none, such as “could do better”. If the employee is steady and reliable, say so plainly, and add one stretch goal that could move them up a rating in the next review.

  1. Meets targets every month and does the job to the standard we agreed.
  2. No missed deadlines this year and reliable on attendance, so the team can plan around this employee.
  3. Handles routine work well; the next step is taking on harder cases without help.
  4. Follows the process correctly; sharing ideas in team meetings would add more value.

Rating 2: Comments for Needs Improvement

These are for an employee who fell short of the target in key areas. The comment must be honest but fair: name the gap with facts, say what support the company will give, and set a clear date to check progress together.

Never leave a needs-improvement comment without a next step, or the employee only hears criticism. Agree on one or two changes, such as a weekly review of the call plan, and record both of them on the appraisal form.

  1. Missed the target in four of six months; we will review the call plan together every week.
  2. Reports often arrive late, which delays payroll; the deadline is the 25th from next month.
  3. Eleven billing errors in the June quarter; a checklist before each bill, reviewed on 30 September, should help.
  4. Asked for help with the March stock report only on the 30th; raising problems by mid-month is the goal.

Rating 1: Comments for Unsatisfactory Work

Use these only when the employee missed the agreed standard by a wide margin, even after support was given. The comment will be read closely if the matter goes further, so stick to dates, numbers and what was already tried.

An unsatisfactory rating should lead to a written performance improvement plan with clear goals and check-ins. Keep the tone calm and factual, and never add remarks about the person’s character, family or private life.

  1. Did not meet the agreed targets in any month, even after the support plan in August.
  2. Was absent on seven days this year without approved leave or a message to the manager.
  3. Broke safety rules twice on the shop floor, after written reminders.
  4. Needs an improvement plan with clear goals and weekly check-ins for the next 60 days.

Pro Tip
I’d suggest reading every comment written for the same rating side by side before the forms are signed. A 4 in one team that reads like a 3 in another shows up at once, before it turns into an unequal raise.

Performance Appraisal Comments by Skill

Many appraisal forms also rate skills, such as quality of work or teamwork. Each skill below has two comments for strong performance and two for areas to improve, and they work as appraisal comments for employees in most roles.

1. Appraisal Comments on Quality of Work

Performance appraisal comments on quality of work should point to accuracy, completeness and how often others had to redo the work. Use a number where you have one, such as errors found in a monthly report or rejected batches.

Quality means different things in different jobs: a clean stock report in a Gurugram warehouse, a correct bill at a front desk, a batch with no rework on a production line. Write the comment in the terms of the employee’s own job.

  1. Work is accurate and complete, with almost no errors in the monthly stock report this year.
  2. Checks the work before passing it on, so others rarely need to redo it.
  3. Work is often rushed in the last hour of the shift; finishing checks earlier would cut errors.
  4. Needs to follow the quality checklist on every batch, not only when the supervisor is present.

2. Appraisal Comments on Job Knowledge

Appraisal comments on job knowledge cover how well the employee knows the products, tools and rules of the role. They suit new joiners who are still learning and experienced staff who keep up as products, tools and rules change.

Link any gap to a training step, so the comment is a plan, not a judgement. A skill matrix helps show which machines or tasks each person can already handle, and what each one should learn next, so the training goal is easy to agree on.

  1. Answered product questions without checking on all three mystery-shopper visits this year.
  2. Keeps up with changes, such as learning the new billing software within a week.
  3. Still relies on others for invoice rules; a short training this quarter would help.
  4. Needs to learn the second machine on the line to cover absences.

3. Appraisal Comments on Initiative

Appraisal comments on initiative describe whether the employee acts without being told, spots problems early and suggests better ways of working. It is also one of the easiest skills to describe in vague words, so the example matters most here.

Always give the example: what the employee noticed, and what they did about it. “Shows initiative” alone tells nobody anything, while “fixed the route plan without being asked” shows the employee exactly what to keep doing.

  1. Spotted a pattern of late deliveries and fixed the route plan without being asked.
  2. Suggested the shared leave calendar that the whole team now uses.
  3. Waits for instructions on routine tasks; the next step is acting first and updating the manager later.
  4. Raised four good ideas in meetings this year but finished none; completing one this quarter is the goal.

4. Appraisal Comments on Teamwork

Performance appraisal comments on teamwork look at how the employee works with colleagues and other departments, shares work at busy times and handles disagreements. They matter most in shift teams, where one gap affects everyone.

Name the team the employee helped, such as stores, accounts or the night shift, so the comment is concrete. Where teamwork needs work, suggest a specific habit, such as joining the weekly review, rather than asking for a better attitude.

  1. Covered for colleagues on six peak-hour shifts this quarter without being asked, and shares credit freely.
  2. Works well with stores and accounts to close the month on time.
  3. Missed three of the four weekly team reviews in March; joining them would help others learn from this employee.
  4. Two disagreements during the July stock count turned into arguments on the floor; raising them in the review meeting keeps them about the work.

5. Appraisal Comments on Communication

Comments on communication cover how clearly the employee speaks and writes to customers, colleagues and managers. In a Pune diagnostic lab or a Chennai hospital, that includes explaining reports to patients’ families in words they understand.

Focus on whether the message reached the right person on time, not on accent or language. A delay reported to the manager the same day is good communication, even when it is only a few short lines sent as a phone message.

  1. Explained test reports to patients’ families in simple words; two thank-you notes in June mention it.
  2. Handover notes were complete on every shift last quarter, so the next shift starts without questions.
  3. Updates on delays come late; telling the manager the same day would help planning.
  4. Emails are long and bury the key point; starting with the decision needed would help.

6. Appraisal Comments on Problem Solving

These comments show whether the employee finds the real cause of a problem and uses facts to decide. They suit supervisors, accounts staff and anyone who reads reports, from a factory floor to a store office or a hospital billing desk.

Credit the method as well as the result: tracing a fault to its cause is the skill. Where the skill is weak, name the step that was skipped, such as checking the totals before a report goes out, so the fix is clear.

  1. Finds the cause, not just the symptom, such as tracing repeat rejections to one worn tool.
  2. Uses numbers to back decisions, such as comparing returns by supplier before reordering.
  3. Sends problems upward that could be solved at this level; trying one fix first is expected.
  4. Needs to check the data before drawing conclusions, as two reports this year had wrong totals.

7. Attendance and Punctuality Comments

These comments should come from the attendance record, not from a manager’s memory. Count late marks and absence without leave, and leave out approved leave, sick leave and holidays the employee was entitled to take.

Quote the period and the number, such as late marks in the last quarter, so the employee can check them. This attendance percentage guide shows how to work the figure out the same way for everyone on the team, whatever their shift.

  1. Never missed a shift without notice and arrived on time all year, even during the monsoon.
  2. Swapped shifts only through the manager all year, so the roster always matched who turned up.
  3. Was late on nine days this quarter; arriving before the shift starts is expected from next month.
  4. Left the shift early on six days this quarter without approval; asking the manager first is expected.

8. Appraisal Comments on Leadership

Comments on leadership are for supervisors, team leaders and managers. They look at how the person builds the team, gives feedback, hands over work, and deals with poor performance before it grows into a bigger problem.

Judge a leader by the team’s results and growth, not only by their own work. A store manager whose team still meets its targets while the manager is on leave has done the leadership part of the job well, whatever their own sales were.

  1. Built a team that meets targets even during the manager’s own leave.
  2. Held a one-on-one with every team member each month, and gave praise in public.
  3. Takes over tasks instead of teaching them; handing over two tasks a month is the goal.
  4. Raised two performance issues only at appraisal time; addressing them within the month is expected.

Overall Performance Appraisal Comments

Overall comments for performance appraisal sum up the year in a short line, usually at the end of the form, and they double as year-end performance review comments. Pick the closest one:

  1. A strong year: targets met in every quarter, and a good example for new joiners.
  2. A steady year with reliable results; the focus for next year is more complex work.
  3. Good progress since the last review, especially on report deadlines.
  4. A difficult year with missed targets; the improvement plan sets out the support we will give.
  5. Ready for a bigger role; a team leader position is worth discussing when one opens.
  6. Mixed results: strong sales but weak collections; improving collections is the main goal next year.

Once the overall comment is final, an increment letter can confirm any raise that follows from it.

Appraisal Comments HR Should Avoid

Some comments make an appraisal unfair, and some can cause legal trouble. Check every form for these before it is shared:

  • Personal remarks without an example, such as “lazy” or “attitude problem”.
  • Anything about age, gender, religion, caste, marriage, pregnancy or health. Rate the work, not the person. The Code on Wages, 2019 also bars gender discrimination in pay for the same or similar work.
  • Approved leave counted against the employee, including sick leave and maternity leave (a benefit the Code on Social Security, 2020 provides).
  • Comparisons with a named colleague, which turn one review into two people’s problem.
  • Vague praise like “good job”, which gives the employee nothing to repeat.

To check that pay is equal for the same work, use this equal pay audit template, which compares pay across the business.

Every rating above rests on records, and attendance records are worth getting right first.

Attendo (formerly Petpooja Payroll) is a complete workforce management system for every kind of business, running attendance, shifts, leaves, payroll and statutory filings in one place. Attendo has more than 40,000 users today. It is Software By Petpooja, building helpful products for Indian businesses since 2011.

Self Appraisal Comments by Employee

Employees write appraisal comments too. Many companies ask employees to rate themselves first, and to reply to the manager’s review at the end. These comments are written in the employee’s own voice.

Sample Self Appraisal Comments

A self appraisal works best when it reads like the manager’s comments: results with numbers, an honest gap, and a goal for next year. Keep each line short, and write about what you did, not what the whole team did, so the manager can check it.

Do not undersell a strong year or hide a weak quarter. Naming a miss and what you changed shows more maturity than a perfect score, and it gives the manager a good reason to agree with the rest of your self appraisal comments.

  1. I met my sales target in nine of twelve months and added 11 new outlets to my beat.
  2. I cut billing errors from about ten a month to two by using a checklist before sending each bill.
  3. I trained two new joiners on the packing line, and they now work on their own.
  4. I covered extra shifts during the festival rush so the store stayed fully staffed.
  5. I want to improve my Excel skills so my reports take less time.
  6. I missed my target in the first quarter; I changed my visit plan and met it from July.
  7. I would like to learn the second machine so I can cover absences.
  8. Next year, I aim to lead a small team.

Employee Comments on Performance Appraisal

Many forms leave space for employee comments on performance appraisal once the manager has written theirs. Use it to agree, to ask for something, or to correct a fact. A short, polite reply is read with more care than a long complaint written in a hurry.

If you disagree with a rating, give the reason with dates or numbers, such as stock arriving late, and ask for it to be noted. Keep a copy of the signed form for your own records, since it may decide your increment and your next role.

  1. I agree with the rating and the goals for next year.
  2. I agree with most of the review, but I request that the June target be adjusted, as the stock arrived three weeks late.
  3. Thank you for the feedback on reporting; I will submit reports by the 25th from next month.
  4. I would like training on the new billing software to meet the goal set for me.

How Attendo Supports Attendance Ratings

Attendo keeps the attendance record that attendance and punctuality comments should come from, built from punches on its devices and its Employee App.

The Attendance Master report shows each employee’s first punch, last punch, working hours and status for every day, and the Muster Report shows full days, half days, absences, leaves and week offs. The words in bold are the names of the app and reports.

The Leave Taken Report lists leave applications and balances, so approved leave is easy to keep out of an attendance comment.

If you want appraisal comments on attendance to come from one record, attendohr.com shows how it works.

What Should an Appraisal Comment Say?

A useful performance appraisal comment has four parts: what the manager saw, a dated example, its effect and a next step. For example, “closed 46 of 50 billing queries on the first call in March” tells an employee what to repeat; “good job” does not.

Start with the rating comment, add skill comments for the two or three skills that matter most in the role, and close with an overall comment. Change every name, date and number so each comment describes the real employee.

Keep each year’s comments on file, so next year’s review can show progress against them.

For owners and HR teams who want attendance comments backed by the same record for everyone, see how Attendo handles attendance and payroll.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How do I write performance appraisal comments?
Say what the employee did, give one dated example, explain its effect and add one next step. Match the tone to the rating.
2. What are good comments for a performance appraisal?
Good comments are specific and fair. For example, “closed 46 of 50 billing queries on the first call in March” beats “good job”.
3. What should I write in a self appraisal?
Write your results with numbers, one honest gap and what you changed, and a goal for next year. Keep each line short.
4. What should an employee write in the comments section?
Agree with the rating, ask for support or training, or correct a fact politely with dates. Keep it short and calm.
5. Can an employee disagree with appraisal comments?
Yes. The employee can write the reason in the comments box, with facts such as dates or numbers, and ask for the point to be reviewed.
6. How long should an appraisal comment be?
One to three sentences per rating or skill is enough, as long as each one carries a real example.
See all results